Mischief is probably best known because of Don’t Bother to Knock, a movie made from the book that featured Marilyn Monroe in her first role where she was one of the featured actors (along with Richard Widmark). From Rich Cypert’s Virtue of Suspense, we learn of the difficulty in selling this story to leading magazines or even to a movie studio because of their ultra-caution about publishing a story about a mentally deranged babysitter. Nevertheless, persistence by Armstrong’s agents resulted in the movie, Don’t Bother to Knock, made by 20thCentry Fox and serialized in Good Housekeeping.
writes: “In Mischief, parents staying
at a hotel leave their young daughter in care of a baby-sitter who turns out to
be mentally unstable. The protagonist, Jed Towers, who meets the baby-sitter by
chance, soon realizes, “She was not a type he knew.’ Although a cynic about the
world, Towers wants a ‘touchstone,’ to believe in people the way his mother who mother who “talked love—was love” did. When
matters get out of hand, Jed extracts himself from the situation, but in the
process of leaving the hotel, he has his epiphany, asking himself, "What
kind of rat did such a thing?" This epiphany eliminates Towers’ earlier
rationalization of his behavior and allows him to test his true mettle.”
book was released in 1951 and, despite difficulties in selling the plot, the
movie was released in 1952, before Marilyn’s affair and marriage to Joe
DiMaggio. The move had quite a cast in addition to the featured stars, such
well-known actors as Ann Bancroft, in her first movie; Jim Backus, of Gilligan’s Island and Mr. Magoo fame; Jeanne Cagney, Jimmy’s
sister; Donna Cochran, Make Room for
Daddy; Verna Felton; Lorene Tuttle and Elisha Cook, Jr.
Marilyn and a stellar cast, the movie
did not fare well to many critics and the box office, but later on more than
one critic thought it to be a movie that showed Monroe really could act. Rotten
Tomatoes which is the leading aggregator of movie reviews gave the movie a rare
100% positive score.
the filming, all of Armstrong’s children had chances to meet the famous actor
while filming. All agree she was drop-dead gorgeous and a very sweet person who
showed more interest in their mother than any of them.
all watched the very recent CNN program, Reframed:
Marilyn Monroe, a documentary
about her life. Her role in Don’t Bother
to Knock was described as Marilyn basically playing herself as a mentally
ill person due to early upbringing. We seriously doubt our mother wrote the
story with that casting in mind as Monroe’s mental problems weren’t revealed
until much later.
sour note about the story: Many years after the film (1991), Fox decided to
remake it as a movie for TV, “The
Sitter.” It was an absolute disaster as they made Nell, the sitter, a
deranged murderess. We were happy our mother never got to see this abomination
and we almost returned the money.